II. Identifying the Risks and Benefits of Moving From Paper to
Electronic Transactions and Records
Documenting Costs and Benefits
After risks are assessed, the costs associated with the electronic transaction
should be documented. There are both technology-related and records-related costs
that should be accounted for. For example, the nice thing about paper records is
that if you put them in a box on the shelf, you’ll be able to read them in
50 or 100 years without having done anything. Put a box of electronic records on a
backup tape, or even the whole server, on a shelf for 50 years, and you almost
certainly will not be able to read them. Imagine the costs of having to photocopy
all paper records in the office every five to ten years to ensure that they remain
readable. If agencies fail to recognize that there will be significant costs in
maintaining electronic records and electronic records systems, they may find
themselves in a real bind in the future. Among the types of costs agencies should
include in their analysis are the following:
-
Design, development, implementation and maintenance of the new system.
-
This should include ongoing operating expenses such as Data Center
chargebacks.
-
Proper migration of electronic records from existing system to the new
system.
-
On-going or continuing maintenance, migration and conservation of
electronic records, especially permanently valuable records.
-
Training of staff and end users.
-
Re-training of staff that may be reassigned to other job duties as a
result of the automation of current processes.
-
New management, administrative and/or process controls required by the
electronic transaction
-
Potential damage to reputation, credibility and public trust
These various costs should then be weighed against the benefits. The following are
examples of potential benefits agencies should include in their analysis:
-
Increased speed of the transaction.
-
Increased partner participation and customer satisfaction.
-
Improved record keeping efficiency and data analysis opportunities.
-
Increased employee productivity and improved quality of the final
product.
-
Greater information benefits to the public, especially for those who
do not live near the agency and will no longer need to travel.
-
Improved security and reduction in fraud.
-
Extensive security for highly sensitive information.
-
Improvement in reputation, credibility and public trust.
In order to create and maintain an electronic transaction system that also allows
for proper electronic records management, the project team should identify and
attempt to mitigate the risks associated with the type of transactions the system
will enable. A cost benefit analysis can help determine how many resources to devote
to mitigating those risks. Once this is completed, then the following guidelines can
be used to develop a more specific set of system requirements that will help ensure
that the system can properly manage the records it creates.